| Poll | Gepresenteerd door | Resultaten |
| "What a Maneuver" of the Year | WWE.com | - Roman Reigns' "Spear"
- Daniel Bryans "Running Knee Strike"
- AJ Lee's "Black Widow"
- Antonio Cesaros "Cesaro Swing"
|
| Faction of the Year | WWE.com | |
| "You Still Got It" (Best Superstar return) of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Couple of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Tag Team of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Feat of Strength of the Year | WWE.com | |
| "Say What" Quote of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Best Dance Moves of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Favorite Web Show of the Year | WWE.com | - The JBL and Cole Show
- WWE Inbox
- 30-Second Fury
- WWE Top 10
|
| Best Crowd of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Catchphrase of the Year | WWE.com | |
| Trending Now (Hashtag) of the Year | Cody Rhodes & Goldust (Pre-Show) | |
| This is Awesome! Moment of the Year | Christian (Pre-Show) | |
| Breakout Star of the Year | John Laurinaitis (Pre-Show) | |
| Beard of the Year | Santino Marella (Pre-Show) | |
| LOL! Moment of the Year | New Age Outlaws (Billy Gunn & Road Dogg) | |
| Double-Cross of the Year | The Shield | |
| Diva of the Year | Eve Torres | |
| Superstar of the Year | Shawn Michaels | |
| Fan Participation of the Year | Prime Time Players | |
| Insult of the Year | The Miz | |
| Extreme Moment of the Year | Mick Foley | |
| Match of the Year | Bret Hart | |
